Toilet training is about timing and routine, not punishment. Harold's approach sets puppies up to succeed rather than waiting to catch them failing.
"Accidents aren't naughtiness. They're a bladder too small to hold on and a routine not yet established."Get Harold's Free Guide Practical help — straight to your inbox.
Harold's approach: "Set them up to succeed outside and they'll get there faster than you think."
Puppies have very small bladders and very short memories. They cannot hold on for long, and they cannot connect a correction to something that happened even a minute ago. This means punishment for accidents is completely pointless — and often makes things worse.
The entire strategy is based on one thing: giving your puppy more opportunities to go in the right place than the wrong one. Take them outside frequently, reward success immediately, and manage the environment to prevent accidents where possible.
Toilet training is a numbers game — more trips outside means more success.
Harold will email it to you right now — practical help for exactly this problem.
🔒 No spam, ever. Unsubscribe any time.
Take your puppy outside first thing in the morning, after every meal, after every nap, after every play session, and before bed. That's a lot of trips — but each one is an opportunity to reinforce the right behaviour. Stand quietly and wait. The moment they go, calm praise immediately.
If an accident happens inside, clean it up without comment. Enzymatic cleaner removes the scent marker that draws them back to the same spot. Increase the frequency of outdoor trips and carry on.
Patience and routine. Every puppy gets there — some just take a little longer.
Most puppies are reliably toilet trained by 4-6 months with consistent application of this routine. Smaller breeds may take longer. Night-time accidents are normal much longer than daytime ones. Remove water an hour before bed and take them out last thing — this reduces but doesn't eliminate night-time accidents.